free html hit counter An Embarrassment of Pitches | John Battelle's Search Blog

An Embarrassment of Pitches

By - February 07, 2013

Man, sometimes you have to venture out onto the real web to realize how far much of the “professional sites” have to travel before they have a viable model.

Case in point: The San Jose Mercury News. Today the paper (yeah, I’m calling it that) published an interesting-sounding piece entitled Silicon Valley job growth has reached dot-com boom levels, report says.  It was widely retweeted and otherwise socially circulated. It’s been a while since the Merc has mattered in my world, and I was pleasantly suprised to see the story pop up in my feeds. So I clicked through to the Actual Web Site to Actually Read The Story.

LordInHeaven I wish I hadn’t. Look at what I saw:

 

Now, it’s going take some work to break down this hot holy mess. So stay with me.

First off, believe it or not the belly flab ad isn’t the worst part of this experience (it’s close, believe me). The worst part is the layout, which looks like – well, something you’d wrap a fish in.

There there are the ads. As the Grinch might say…the ads ads ads ads. Six or more of them in this screenshot, and three more below the fold. There’s a Verizon site wrapper (on either side of the page), an expandable top banner, and three medium rectangle units crammed in there. Not one of them is what you might call a “quality” ad – at least by most standards. (Do you think Verizon is happy that their site takeover is overrun by social media buttons and competing with belly flab, diabetes, Frys’ Electronics and travel pitches?) If you bother to scroll down (who would?) there are three more pitches waiting for you there.

And check out the number of beacons and trackers on the right, in purple. That’s Ghostery, which I run on my browser to see who’s laying down data traps. Man, Merc, that’s a lot o’ data. Are you doing anything with it? (I’m guilty of the same, as a commentator points out below.)

It’s late, I’ll stop. But before I go, one more thing: I just don’t believe that’s the same person Before and After in that belly fat ad. Oh, and what was I reading again? Ah, never mind.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • NRG

    pot/black? I added ghostery to my browser. Then I went to merc and they had 48 in the ghostery list. I came here to comment and you have 34 in your list!

    • johnbattelle

      You are not kidding. It’s a mess here on Searchblog. But the layout is the real issue, not to mention, I have three ads on the page, not 10.

      • NRG

        You’d think a “newspaper” would now a little something about layout!!

        • johnbattelle

          The page kind of looks like an old school newspaper had sex with an old school penny saver

  • http://twitter.com/emeyerson EMey

    I just clicked on the article. The Verizon wrapper is now gone. But I got TWO — not one but TWO — pop-up ads.

    • johnbattelle

      Wow, you lucky!

  • http://twitter.com/alston Alston Cheek

    From a user prospective, (beacons and trackers aside) ad layouts like this are on my radar less and less as I find myself consuming web content via ‘read it later’ services like instapaper that scrub out this garbage. If I must read in a browser, Safari’s ‘Reader’ does a nice job of displaying only editorial content. I realize this missies your point of big data collection but wanted to point out the emerging set of workarounds available to avoid laying eyes on page layouts like this.

    • johnbattelle

      Given your and many others reading habits (I read in RSS most of the time and have for years) you’re making my point, more elegantly: Publishers have to change how they deliver their product, and how it’s accompanied by commercial partnerships. Hence our focus on “native”….

      • http://twitter.com/alston Alston Cheek

        The Atlantic is doing a nice job of this with qz.com.

        • johnbattelle

          Agreed

  • http://twitter.com/maniballi Michael

    I do this for a living for one of the oldest ad agencies in North America…and i am in total agreement John….but if the proof point for the rise of digital is the metric of increasing digital media dollars being spent, and THIS is what it is spent on….the 30 second spot is due to make a comeback….

    • johnbattelle

      I still think we can figure out a better unit that works for all.

  • http://twitter.com/BeerBizDaily Harry Schuhmacher

    My grandfather owned the San Antonio Express. Hearst owns it now and they can have it. I now own Beer Business Daily. No advertising, but $580 a year to subscribe. I started BBD fifteen years ago, good biz. I took the WSJ and FT model of publishing…. people in a niche will pay.

  • george

    Maybe the SJM know’s what they are doing – nailing their target audience? Definitely applying the shotgun approach – there’s a little something for everyone. Shame, I once had them bookmarked but now there’s way too much going on…

  • http://twitter.com/mkstevenson Michael K Stevenson

    “But before I go, one more thing: I just don’t believe that’s the same person Before and After in that belly fat ad.”

    This is amazing!

  • Ina Steiner

    At least you can tell those are ads. As we recently reported, news sites
    are using VigLInk and Skimlinks to earn affiliate revenue by linking to products
    w/out disclosing they’re earning money off the content. http://www.ecommercebytes.com/cab/abn/y13/m01/i28/s04 As I
    wrote, “simply take a product for which you have an affiliate link and wrap a
    news story around it.”

  • raj

    horrific — no doubt. but john, isn’t this the world that context-less audience targeting creates? real time bidding which is generating 40% + margins to agencies and flooding google’s coffers is driving down cpms and sucking all the revenue away from publishers. so this is the web experience that results.

    • johnbattelle

      I highly doubt 40% margins to agencies. That sounds like a fantasy…

      • raj

        That’s what they’re making — info straight from folks at Google’s Intent media. Haven’t you noticed Sir Martin’s stopped complaining about disintermediation? RTB isn’t growing because it’s more effective, it’s because it’s more profitable. No one’s reporting on where the margin is going…

  • rondavis

    At least you can tell those are ads. As we recently reported, news sites
    are using VigLInk and Skimlinks to earn affiliate revenue by linking to products
    w/out disclosing they’re earning money off the content.
    Freelance job training in Bangladesh

  • Pingback: Identity vs Irrelevance « Designs By Brian