free html hit counter Google Local Upgrade | John Battelle's Search Blog

Google Local Upgrade

By - March 03, 2005

Local Hp LogoGoogle today introduced upgrades to Google Local, taken together they point to some interesting trends in Google’s approach to this market.

First, Google has integrated its broadly acclaimed Google Maps application, not a surprising move. Second, and more interestingly, Google has incoporated reviews. But unlike Yahoo, which allows for users to submit reviews at the point of search, Google crawls the web for reviews which are already extant, then rolls them into its results. Users cannot add their own reviews on the spot.

This is an important distinction, and yet another declaration of how Google differs from its competitors, in particular Yahoo. I’ve written about this here and here (and a lot of other places). Blogger aside (and there’s plenty to say about the limitations of that platform), Google has always been uncomfortable with user created content, at least on its main site. While sites like Amazon, eBay, and Yahoo are full bore participants in the architecture of participation (AOP), Google prefers to lay an algorithm between user created content and its own search service. It’s still AOP, but it’s AOP once removed.

Why am I on about this? Well, Yahoo’s approach allows merchants to join the AOP party, and start paying for listings, for example. Google’s approach – at least so far – eschews this potential revenue stream. Again, Google seems to be avoiding the deeper media play.

This is not a criticism, per se, just an observation. The new Google Local also scans the web for other useful information such as prices, hours of operation, and so on. On first blush, the new service looks greatly improved. But I wonder if the approach – of filtering the web rather than engaging an AOP based platform – will really work for users. We’ll see. It’s great that there are such distinct approaches to the same market – it means we’ll all learn more, more quickly.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

4 thoughts on “Google Local Upgrade

  1. Fred Langin says:

    Speaking of the “architecture of participation, once removed”, Google seems to be testing a new feature:

    http://downloadaborted.blogspot.com/

  2. I provide some ideas on how Google could dominate in providing local search AND the way it is done (thru PC or mobile).

    http://theponderingprimate.blogspot.com/2005/03/google-heres-what-you-should-do.html

  3. Sam says:

    Local search is not just yellow page results, or cross match yellow pages with web pages.

    There is lot of valuable local information out there in the Internet. Atlocal is a new local search engine that does it differently than Google Local.

    Check it out at:
    http://www.atlocal.com/

  4. Zhenlei Cai says:

    I think Google with its vast PageRank scores on review sites, knows what reviews are more reliable. That’s why it gather those reviews rathers than let average Joe post one.